Trader Alpha
Menu
BROKER HEAD-TO-HEAD

IG vs Pepperstone: UK spreads, commission and financing

Spread-bet and CFD account pricing are not the same thing; compare like for like.

By Steven Smith · Editorial review 21 November 2026 · Desk research, not live account testing

Answer: Spread-bet and CFD account pricing are not the same thing; compare like for like. The useful comparison is the all-in cost for the right product and jurisdiction, not an unsupported winner.

Disclosure: Independent educational comparison of public broker information. No commissionable referral link is active. CFDs and spread betting are leveraged and high risk; their availability differs by location. No recommendation to open an account.

Published fees and the product behind them

ProviderProduct focusPublished information and conditionsOriginal source
IGSpread bets and CFDsUK fee schedule lists minimum EUR/USD spread 0.6 points and an S&P 500 spread from 0.5 points for one trading arrangement. Minimum spreads are not an average or execution test.Official published terms ↗
PepperstoneFX/CFDs and spread bettingUK Razor account advertises forex spreads from 0.0 plus commission from £2.25 per lot per side; Standard incorporates the FX charge into the spread. Both are product-specific advertised conditions.Official published terms ↗

Why these conditions matter

The comparison needs an identical instrument, account type, currency, position size, holding period and regulatory jurisdiction. Comparing an advertised minimum spread against a different product commission would not be a fair cost test.

Like-for-like product, licence and account entity; cash shares versus CFDs; execution fees, financing and FX conversion.

The question this comparison must answer

What is the total cost of the same £5,000 transaction at each provider?

Any test that claims a winner should record the same date and time, identical product, account currency, quote size and holding period, plus deposits, withdrawals and the resulting all-in cost. Without that, the observation is desk research rather than an execution review.

What our next live test must capture

We intend to capture spread and price snapshots around 08:05 and 14:35 London time, then log order fills, commission, currency conversion, platform behaviour, deposit/withdrawal timestamps and any overnight financing. We will publish only results we actually obtained; these tests are pending.

Why a 0.0-pip headline is not a zero-cost trade

Pepperstone's UK Razor documentation advertises FX spreads starting from 0.0 and commissions from £2.25 per lot per side. That is £4.50 per lot in opening and closing commissions before spread, financing or other instrument-dependent costs, using the advertised starting rate. IG's UK charges list minimum EUR/USD spreads around 0.6 points for one account arrangement. Comparing the two numbers without both sides of the transaction and the exact account is misleading: commission-based FX CFDs and spread-bet products have different fee structures.

Check the original published evidence ↗

A £10-per-point index spread example

If an index spread were 0.5 points at the instant of execution, a £10-per-point position would incur an illustrative £5 spread crossing cost, assuming no price movement. IG lists a 0.5-point minimum S&P 500 spread for a relevant account schedule; the live spread may be wider. The broker can also charge overnight financing on daily cash positions. This does not prove that another broker's index product is dearer or cheaper because order size, tax rules, execution and financing differ.

Check the original published evidence ↗

How the London and New York opens should be tested

Capture simultaneous executable bid/ask quotes in funded UK accounts at 08:05 and 14:35 London time, recording the same EUR/USD symbol, quote size, product, timestamp, account tier, commission and after-market spread. Repeat across at least 20 sessions, then compare medians, 90th-percentile spread, range and slippage. We have not performed this real-account test, so the only numerical findings here are broker-published terms and illustrative arithmetic.

Check the original published evidence ↗

Want the fee checklist and next tests?

Get independent fee and platform updates in the Trader Alpha newsletter. We do not add subscribers from another business.

Get the daily briefing ↗ Calculate trading costs ↗

Frequently asked questions

What should I compare first?

What is the total cost of the same £5,000 transaction at each provider? Start with the regulated legal entity and the exact product, then add spread, commission, FX conversion, funding and any platform/custody fees.

Which provider is cheapest?

No provider is declared cheapest on this page. We have not completed comparable funded-account execution tests across the named providers. The provider-document facts above are the current evidence base.

What does this research actually test?

It checks published fee and account documentation dated 21 November 2026. It does not claim live market execution, service responsiveness or withdrawals have been personally tested.

Can I access the same products in the US and UK?

Not necessarily. Every provider has local legal entities, product permissions and market-specific rules. A US share-dealing account, a UK ISA and a UK CFD cannot be treated as the same service.

Does a broker partnership affect the comparison?

No active commissionable tracking link is used on this page. Any future affiliate arrangement must be disclosed and must not change the methodology or eligibility by country.

What would change the assessment?

Published fee changes, verified live bid/ask samples, fill data, a dated account test and eligible product availability would trigger a review and an updated timestamp.

Primary sources

Continue researching